BJP and AAP raise questions over claims of Indira Gandhi’s regret and delay in army deployment; Congress leaders say they will comment after reading the book.
Chandigarh: Even after more than four decades since the 1984 Sikh massacre, the political controversy over the issue shows no sign of stopping. The mention of Operation Blue Star and the November 1984 Sikh massacre in the new memoir ‘Belonging: A Journey of Love’ by Congress Parliamentary Party Chairperson Sonia Gandhi has sparked a fresh debate. In the book, Sonia Gandhi has claimed that seeing the pictures of the damage caused to Sri Harmandir Sahib and Sri Akal Takht Sahib brought tears to the eyes of then Prime Minister Indira Gandhi. Cornering the Congress over this statement, the BJP has demanded a public apology from the Sikh community.
In her 544-page book, Sonia Gandhi has described the 1984 Sikh massacre as a painful chapter in the country’s history. She has acknowledged that it has been extremely difficult for the victims to get justice in this matter. According to her, despite the formation of four commissions, nine committees, and two special investigation teams regarding this, the process of punishing the culprits remained incomplete. She also wrote that criminal cases were registered against many people, including some Congress workers, on charges of inciting or directing violence. Apart from this, there is also mention of cases registered against RSS members on charges of being involved in the massacre.
Tears in Indira Gandhi’s eyes after Operation Blue Star

Referring to the June 1984 Operation Blue Star in her book, Sonia Gandhi has written that Indira Gandhi ordered the military action after much deliberation and anxiety. According to her, after the presence of heavy weapons in the Sri Harmandir Sahib complex and casualties on both sides, the army recaptured the complex, but the holy shrine suffered considerable damage during this action.
She claimed that a few days after the operation, an intelligence officer showed Indira Gandhi a film containing pictures of its consequences. These pictures showed the bodies of the people killed, weapons, and the destruction caused by the military action. According to Sonia, seeing this sight, there were tears in Indira Gandhi’s eyes, which reflected her pain, remorse, and sorrow for the large number of deaths.
Mention of November 1984 massacre and delay in army deployment
Sonia Gandhi has written that after the assassination of Indira Gandhi, Sikhs were targeted in many places including Delhi. According to her, more than 2,000 Sikhs were killed in Delhi alone. She has also raised questions on the failure of the administration, the role of the police, and the delay in army deployment.
In her narrative, she stated that the family later learned about the order received by Army Chief General A.S. Vaidya on the night of Indira Gandhi’s assassination. According to Sonia, instead of immediately using the army units present near Delhi, the army was called from Dehradun, and soldiers started reaching Delhi on the night of November 1. She also wrote that some officials failed to stop the violence, while some may have turned a blind eye or encouraged it.
BJP demands apology from Sonia Gandhi
Senior advocate H.S. Phoolka has questioned the narrative given in Sonia Gandhi’s book regarding the delay in army deployment during the 1984 Sikh massacre. He said that Sonia Gandhi has blamed the decision of then Army Chief General Vaidya for this delay, whereas the reports of the Mishra and Nanavati Commissions do not match this claim.
According to Phoolka, 6,100 soldiers were present in Delhi on the night of October 31 and the morning of November 1, but they were not deployed in time. He questioned that if Rajiv Gandhi was aware of the situation, what action was taken against the administrative failure and those who allegedly provided political protection to the culprits? Phoolka said that the narrative presented in Sonia Gandhi’s book clashes with official reports and is an attempt to give a clean chit to the Gandhi family.
Questions also raised on Sonia’s narrative about army deployment
The BJP has also challenged the narrative given in Sonia Gandhi’s book regarding the delay in army deployment. In its official statement, citing the reports of the Mishra Commission and the Nanavati Commission, the BJP claimed that around 6,100 army personnel were present in Delhi on the night of October 31 and the morning of November 1, but they were not deployed in time.
According to the BJP’s statement, the Mishra Commission had said that if around 5,000 soldiers had been deployed on the streets of Delhi on the morning of November 1, the lives of at least 2,000 Sikhs could have been saved. The party also claimed that General Vaidya had never said that Rajiv Gandhi or the Prime Minister had asked him to call the army. The BJP has also raised questions about the accountability of the administrative machinery and the role of the central government at that time.
BJP MP Satnam Singh Sandhu also raised questions
BJP MP Satnam Singh Sandhu also raised the question that if Indira Gandhi was remorseful about the injustice done to Sikhs and the damage caused to the holy shrine, then how did the massacre of Sikhs take place after her assassination. He alleged that before the violence, the houses of Sikhs were identified and marked. He demanded that the Congress fix responsibility for this.
AAP leader Saurabh Bharadwaj’s statement on Sonia Gandhi’s book
On Sonia Gandhi’s comments about 1984 in ‘Belonging: A Journey of Love’, AAP Delhi President Saurabh Bharadwaj said that the military action on the Golden Temple with cannons and heavy weapons and the massacre of Sikhs on the streets of Delhi had raised questions on the secularism of the Congress.
He said that Sonia Gandhi is now trying to help people recover from those wounds, but if Indira Gandhi had expressed regret at that time, it would have been much more significant. Bharadwaj termed this statement of Sonia Gandhi as a claim that cannot be independently verified and which should be viewed in the context of the current political environment.
Congress leaders say they will comment after reading the book
On the other hand, Congress leader Anand Sharma said that the BJP should read Sonia Gandhi’s book before attacking it. He said that no one defended what happened in 1984. According to him, he would be able to make any detailed comment on it only after reading the book.
Congress leader Salman Khurshid also said that everyone was deeply sorry for what happened at that time. He said that an attempt to change the system through violence in a democracy cannot be acceptable to anyone. He stated the need to read the book in detail before giving any final opinion on Sonia Gandhi’s statement and said that an official reaction would also be given by the party in due time.
Sonia Gandhi has also said in her book that the 1984 massacre was not a symbol of any deep enmity between the Congress and the Sikh community. In this regard, she later cited the electoral victories of the Congress in Punjab. However, her narrative and claims regarding Indira Gandhi’s regret have now become a subject of political debate. Even after more than four decades, the questions of justice, accountability, and apology for the victims of 1984 remain crucial in the Sikh community and the country’s politics.



Leave a Comment